Hall of Fame candidate Shaun Alexander played his entire career under Stump. He made the Pro Bowl in 2003, 2004 and 2005. In 2005 he was named NFL MVP.

Undrafted out of college, Strong became a Pro Bowler twice, in 2005 and 2006. He was considered one of the best blocking full backs in the league under Stump.

A 12-year yeoman running back, Mike Sellers, who spent time in the CLF and NFL had his one and only pro bowl season in 2006 under Stump. One of only two seasons Stump was his coach.

David Johnson became known as one the rising stars in the NFL after just two seasons in the NFL, both under Stump. In his second year, 2016, Johnson ran for 1,239 yards, caught for 879 yards and had 20 touchdowns. He was also named a first-team pro bowler.